In August 1938, four years after he completed writing the Brotherhood of Light lessons, Elbert Benjamine wrote:
‘The Church of Light is under no illusion that all essential information is contained within the 21 courses of Brotherhood of Light lessons. It does believe, however, that these twenty-one courses afford a very good foundation upon which to build. And it believes that the Hermetic system of astrology is the most satisfactory, and the one in which research work can be spent to the best advantage.
There is such a tremendous amount of research work that needs to be done in connection with Hermetic astrology that it will tax the initiative and combined efforts of all our ministers and teachers for scores of years to come. And with such a vast amount of astrological ore waiting to be mined, it seems wasteful to scatter the efforts to other astrological veins, many of which are sure to yield nothing of worth.
Without departing from the Hermetic system of astrology, there are new and important discoveries yet to be made, to satisfy the most ardent astrological explorer. The field of what needs to be known, and still remains to be discovered, is almost limitless.
And this also may be said of all the other matters treated in the 210 regular Brotherhood of Light lessons. These lessons, as published, are only the beginning of occult knowledge. They include what we know today; and I believe, as far as they go, they will stand up under the most exacting tests. But they do not contain vast funds of knowledge which Church of Light ministers and teachers will discover tomorrow.
The Church of Light wishes to offer every encouragement to its ministers, its teachers and its students to explore and make new discoveries. All such discoveries which are reported to us will receive attention in due course of time. In the discovery of worthwhile facts, we need all the brains of all our ministers, teachers and students.
Now that the foundation, as embraced in the 21 courses, has been laid, the building of the real edifice of The Religion of the Stars becomes a strictly cooperative venture. Its soundness and its value are not dependent upon a few individuals, but upon the energy, intelligence and diligence of every minister, teacher and student, each contributing what lies within his or her power toward its perfection.
Before going into the structure submitted material must be given a thorough testing. If it is astrological, it must stand the test of the statistical method. If not astrological, it must stand other tests which will be devised. It is a great and glorious work, in which, I am sure you will feel proud to take a part in.’
And from then to 1948 statistical research into birth charts provided a vast amount of new astrological discoveries: What makes a waiter? What makes a telephone operator? What makes a bookkeeper? What makes a stenographer? What makes an artist? What makes a store clerk? When do people have infantile paralysis? What makes an electrician? What makes an athlete? What makes an architect? What makes a professional dancer? When do people have surgical operations? When do people have appendicitis? What makes a chemist? When do people receive honors? When are people benefitted by friends? When do people have cancer? Thoughts which prevent automobile accidents. Thoughts which prevent influenza. Thoughts which prevent heart trouble. Thoughts which prevent scarlet fever. Thoughts which prevent nervous breakdown. Thoughts which prevent tonsil trouble. Thoughts which prevent paralysis. Thoughts which prevent eye trouble. And thoughts which prevent ear trouble.
Church of Light members and ministers participated in the development of astrodynes in 1946; and they contributed to the discovery of the role played by minor progressions and transit progressions in timing major events.
In August 1951 in regard to the discovery of new astrological facts Elbert explained that they should be submitted to The Church of Light Board of Directors to secure their approval and should appear and be explained and elaborated upon in an appendix of the Brotherhood of Light lessons with the discoverer’s name. He wrote: ‘It would be unethical for someone to inset opinions or discoveries and not take both the credit and the blame for them.’
He explained: ‘In reprinting it is easy to increase any lesson to 36 or 40 pages or any multiple of four pages.’ And suggested: ‘Any errors he has made, or new discoveries, or logical opinions derived from them these discoveries, be set forth and elaborated in an appendix following the 32 pages of the lesson which it is thought should be amended.’
But 50 years later the Church of Light in Los Angeles, California was a train wreck. Members squabbled and pursued self-interest; and with no expert teachers the general level of astrological understanding had deteriorated rapidly. No astrological research was being conducted. Church of Light board members and other longtime members lacked the expertise to do it.
But in Australia Dennis Sutton was conducting research to verify the findings of previous Church of Light research which he thought may have been compromised by unreliable birth times and uncertain criterion.
The original Church of Light statistical research was conducted using a planet prominence rule and in 2015 he conducted an investigation into its accuracy and reliability. (An investigation to test the accuracy and reliability of the planet prominence rule self-published in 2015.)
To do the test he established a new astrodyne power rule: a planet was prominent when it had above average astrodyne power. And compared the findings based on this rule with those found using the old planet prominence rule.
He concluded: ‘Every chart that was examined displayed planet prominence irregularities. A planet judged prominent by house was found to have below average power and a planet not rated as prominent was found to have above average power. In a large number of instances, a planet rated prominent, in a chart that participated in a particular research project, was found to have below average power – a situation that compromises the validity of the original research.
Whether the above average astrodyne power rule is valid for judging a planet’s prominence remains to be seen, but the information provided by this research project should get the Mercury thought-cells buzzing! The establishment of a set criterion for determining planet prominence using the planet power summary should be high on the research astrologer’s agenda.
New guidelines for determining planet prominence must be set and these guidelines – no matter what time, effort and energy it takes – must be 100% reliable and evidence-based. If the guidelines are too broad, or indefinite, the information they provide will lack accuracy, usefulness and scientific credibility.’
And during the course of his research into the reliability of the planet prominence rule he made a discovery.
The Church of Light teaches: ‘Each reinforced major progressed constant of an event is always released by a transit aspect heavier than the Moon to one of the four terminals (the birth chart and progressed positions of the aspecting planets) at the time the event occurs.’
In other words: The event indicated by a reinforced progressed aspect is timed by a transit aspect (not the Moon) to one of the birth chart or progressed planets involved in the aspect.
And he discovered that the transit aspect that times the event (by a transiting planet, ascendant or Midheaven [not the Moon]) is always to the planet ruling the house which is the event’s constant.
You need some understanding of the rules regarding the timing of major events so, when you shoot the past with progressed chart freeze-frames to determine what thought-cells were involved in attracting a major event into your life pay attention to the transit progressions to the planet ruling the house directly involved in the event.
This discovery by Dennis Sutton is the only new astrological fact discovered in the past 75 years. His research proved a previous taught rule was incorrect, but it is not a Church of Light teaching.
Because its board of directors had little or no understanding of the science of natal astrology and the rules pertaining to the timing of major events in natal astrology, he decided not to waste his time bringing his discovery to their attention.
It’s implied that Church of Light board members are Hermeticians who have a superior understanding of the Brotherhood of Light teachings but over the past 50 years some weren’t Hermeticians and many were recruited just to make up the numbers unaware of their fiduciary duties and other responsibilities. They all had a shallow understanding of the Brotherhood of Light’s knowledge-base.
As board members they didn’t know that their ‘energy, intelligence and diligence’ was expected to contribute to the soundness, value and eventual perfection of The Religion of the Stars.
In 2026 the 210 Brotherhood of Light lessons remain unchanged yet the development of astrodynes revolutionized the birth chart’s assessment rendering previous teachings redundant and necessitating some revision to lessons in course 10-1; and mundane astrology continually moves forward necessitating continual revision of the lessons in Cours 13.
Astrology for Aquarius teaches the assessment of the birth chart using a revised method based on the astrodyne measurements and continually works to stay abreast of mundane developments in a fast-changing world.
CC Zain aka Elbert Benjamine requested that the 210 Brotherhood of Light lessons by revised as necessitated by new scientific discoveries that proved that what he had written was incorrect due to new astrological research, new discoveries that provided additional facts and by changes necessitated by the course of time, but the Church of Light board of directors has failed to do as he requested on all counts.
Since Elbert completed his final revisions to the lessons in 1948 board members have found no need to correct any errors or insert important new discoveries. In regard to astrological research, it seems that the well of astrological knowledge dried up. Apparently, there weren’t any new astrological facts to discover and that was that.
Astrology for Aquarius – sharing our knowledge